2018 Annual Report: Delivering, Engaging and Responding

Introduction

While 2018 saw positive economic growth for many African countries, translating this growth into sustained and inclusive development which improves the lives of their citizens is challenging and will require significant socio-economic transformation. Many African countries on this path struggle with developing measurable, relevant outcome indicators, monitoring them and using that information to make adjustments. In order to successfully drive transformation, governments need credible, effective monitoring and evaluation tools that enable them to learn from successes and failures.

In supporting the African transformation agenda, multilateral development institutions such as the African Development Bank (AfDB or the Bank) understand the need to be innovative, flexible and responsive to fast-changing realities and clients’ needs. Central to their ability to respond to needs and to effect positive change, is the capacity to review and learn from experience, and to subsequently adjust and improve policies, processes and programs in a culture of evaluation, learning and results. Independent Development Evaluation (IDEV) supports the Bank’s capacity to learn from what has worked, what has not, and why, in order to strengthen its development interventions in its member countries.

This year’s Annual Report focuses on how IDEV delivered evaluative knowledge; engaged with Bank operations departments, stakeholders and partners to strengthen its products and build a culture of evaluation within the Bank and in African countries; and responded to evaluation needs, demand and changes. It also highlights how IDEV continued to strengthen the evaluation function, including undergoing a self- and an external assessment, in order to draw lessons and further improve the quality and impact of its work.

Download Annual Report

Message from the AfDB CODE Chair

"The international discourse on evaluation has evolved considerably over the last few decades. Whilst evaluation was initially treated simply as an accountability tool, today it has become a fundamental and indispensable instrument for learning and decision-making".

Message from the AfDB Acting Evaluator General

"In a year that evaluation and evaluators worldwide were called upon to “speak truth to power”, to contribute to more resilient societies, to promote evidence-informed decision-making, and to help strengthen development impact, I am proud to share how IDEV contributed to the achievement of these goals, by delivering evaluative knowledge, engaging with stakeholders, and responding to needs and demand."

 

Message from the AfDB Senior Vice President

"Africa’s real GDP grew by 3.5% in 2018 and is forecast to grow by 4.1% in 2019. The strong economic growth is a result of massive investments in infrastructure, improvements in the investment climate, the recovery in commodity prices and increased domestic demand, amongst other factors."

 

 

Delivering evaluative knowledge

As an independent unit tasked with enhancing the development effectiveness of the Bank, delivering and sharing evaluative knowledge is a core activity of IDEV and its raison d’être. IDEV conducts independent evaluations of the Bank’s policies, strategies, processes and operations and proactively shares good practices. This is to ensure that the Bank and its stakeholders learn from experience to plan and deliver development results to the highest possible standards. These evaluations also provide a basis for accountability to key stakeholders including citizens, governments, funders and partners, by evaluating and documenting the impact of the Bank’s activities.

IDEV delivered a record number of evaluation products in 2018, in a shifting and at times challenging environment (see the section “Responding to changes and challenges”).

See 2018 evaluations  |  Download Annual Report

 

Engaging with stakeholders for better evaluations and a culture of learning

As part of its mandate to promote learning and build an evaluation culture both in the Bank and in its Regional Member Countries, IDEV goes beyond simply making evaluative knowledge available through dissemination of reports, briefs, and other knowledge products. It also reaches out and engages with key stakeholders through events and digital platforms.

Since the Bank adopted its Independent Evaluation Strategy, IDEV has made strides in fostering closer relationships within the Bank as well as with external partners and stakeholders in order to build a culture of evaluation and learning inside the AfDB, within governments, parliaments and other decision making institutions across Africa, and among development agencies.

In 2018, IDEV enhanced its engagement with Bank operations departments, through closer cooperation in the design and conduct of evaluations, including through reference groups. It also launched a series of capitalization workshops, a platform for IDEV and Bank operations staff to discuss findings, lessons and recommendations from evaluations and foster improved project designs and strategies. This enhanced engagement has helped to instill a stronger culture of learning at the Bank, where evaluations are increasingly seen a seen as a source of knowledge with the aim of improved performance, rather than purely an accountability mechanism. Furthermore, IDEV engages with partners and networks in order to further the use of evaluation and evaluative knowledge for accountability and policy- and decision-making in African countries.

See 2018 news stories  |  Download Annual Report

 

Responding to evaluation needs, demands and changes

In order for IDEV’s evaluations to achieve their objective of improving development effectiveness, they not only need to be accurate, credible and of high quality, they also need to be relevant and useful. IDEV is therefore very careful in deciding what should be evaluated and what kind of evaluations are  necessary (i.e. where learning is needed) as well as wanted by the users (i.e. the AfDB Board, Bank operations departments, etc.).

IDEV works on the basis of a three-year work program, approved by the AfDB Board, the most recent of which was completed at the end of 2018. The work program is established through a consultative process with the AfDB Board and Management, whereby the most relevant, useful and pressing requests for evaluation are considered. During the implementation of the work program, each year IDEV discusses adjustments to the work program with the AfDB Board’s Committee on Operations and Development Effectiveness (CODE) in terms of priorities; this allows for evaluations to be added, dropped or postponed as per changing circumstances and the needs of the Bank. This gives IDEV the flexibility to respond to shifting needs and demands.

Find ongoing evaluations  |  Download Annual Report

 

Further strengthening the evaluation function

IDEV continually explores ways to strengthen the evaluation function and make its work more relevant for the Bank. For example, it participates in several evaluation networks focused on standard-setting, experience-sharing and peer learning, to stay abreast of the latest developments in international evaluation theory and practice and to learn from the good practices of other evaluation offices. In 2018, it also introduced a number of measures designed to further enhance the quality of its evaluations. Moreover, it undertook a self-assessment of the implementation of the Independent Evaluation Strategy and underwent an external quality review of its evaluation products as well as an Independent Peer Review by members of the Evaluation Cooperation Group. These assessments provided various lessons and recommendations and will form the basis for a discussion by CODE in early 2019 on the strategic directions for IDEV going forward.

See IDEV's strategic directions  |  Download Annual Report

 

 

The road ahead

IDEV has a large number of evaluations ongoing (see Annex 2), which in 2019 will provide valuable findings, lessons and recommendations for the Bank’s policies, strategies, operations and processes. These include three project cluster evaluations, two impact evaluations, four CSPEs, three sector and thematic evaluations, six corporate evaluations, and two evaluation syntheses. Guided by a new Work Program for 2019-2021, IDEV looks forward to starting new evaluations, engaging better with stakeholders including with Management and Bank operations departments, sharing its knowledge to promote accountability and learning from evaluations, participating in international events like the AfrEA conference, contributing to capacity development on the continent, and applying the lessons and recommendations from the self-assessment and the Independent Peer Review. A discussion with CODE on the strategic directions for the department will provide further guidance and impetus to the evaluation function. Finally, the new Evaluator General will be warmly welcomed among IDEV staff next year.

Go to IDEV work progam |  Download Annual Report