IDEV carried out a validation of the African Development Bank’s Country Strategy Paper (CSP) Completion Report (2021–2025) for Seychelles. The validation aimed to enhance accountability and learning by independently reviewing the quality and credibility of the Completion Report and the results it presented. It examined whether the results were supported by evidence, how well internal and external influencing factors were identified, and the extent to which lessons could inform future country strategies.
The validation found that the Completion Report was generally of good quality, offering a comprehensive and objective assessment of the CSP’s program performance supported by tangible evidence. It effectively identified key factors influencing implementation and highlighted unexpected positive effects, notably strengthened institutional capacities. Data collection and analysis were robust, with active stakeholder participation and strong alignment with Bank reporting standards.
However, several gaps were identified. The Completion Report did not sufficiently address negative unexpected effects or fully analyze the implications of program adjustments, including increased reliance on budget support. Coverage of cross-cutting issues was partial, and evidence of contributions to the Ten-Year Strategy 2013-2022 and High 5 priorities was weak.
Key lessons:
- Flexible programs are needed to address evolving challenges, e.g., during Covid 19 pandemic.
- Integrating technical assistance can boost capacity, improve implementation, and efficiency.
- Strong project design and risk analysis improve selectivity and strategic focus.
- Timely CSP adjustment is vital to ensure strategy relevance, effectiveness and sustainability.
- Active stakeholder engagement ensures sustainability, and effective CSP implementation.
- Regular and structured dialogue with policymakers and donors enhances budget support relevance and coherence.
Task Manager: Mabarakissa Diomande, Principal Evaluation Officer, IDEV