South Africa : Evaluation of the AfDB Country Strategy and Program (2004-2015)

Date: 03/04/2017

Type: Country strategy and program evaluation

Country(ies): South Africa

Status: Completed

Independent Development Evaluation (IDEV) has carried out an evaluation of the Country Strategy and Program of the African Development Bank Group (“the Bank”) in South Africa  over the period 2004-2015. The evaluation is intended to inform the next country strategy paper (CSP) due in 2018; and to contribute to accountability and learning. To provide solid evidence for its findings, the evaluation included thorough project assessments and reviewed the broader portfolio of strategies and of non-lending activities. It answers questions about how the Bank is managing itself, what it has achieved, and the lessons learned based on what has helped or hindered performance. Finally, it proposes recommendations designed to help the Bank improve its future performance in South Africa.

The evaluation found a Bank that is learning to adapt to the developed, competitive South African market. It highlighted the fact that while the scope and scale of Bank operations cannot make a significant national impact, they are nevertheless important for the Bank. The findings showed that the Bank was moving in a relevant direction given its objectives, but that gaps exist in key areas and that ambitions were ill matched to available resources, instruments and demand. The evaluation raised concerns about efficiency (timeliness and processes) and effectiveness (in relation to Bank targets). 

The evaluation themes provide insights for future business development in South Africa, and possibly in other Regional Member Countries. These include better identifying the Bank’s comparative advantage and competitiveness, the suitability of its financing instruments and activities. The experience in South Africa around
energy, leveraging finance, syndication and lines of credit could also serve operations in other countries.

Task Manager : Penelope Jackson