Independent Development Evaluation (IDEV) carried out a validation of the African Development Bank’s Country Strategy Paper (CSP) Completion Report (2015-2025) for Chad. The validation aimed at assessing learning and accountability, thereby supporting the Bank’s efforts to enhance the quality of CSPs and their operational effectiveness, as well as the quality of the completion reports drafted at the end of the Bank’s various strategies and programmes. It also assessed the credibility, analytical rigor and soundness of the conclusions in the CSP-CR, rather than evaluating the CSP’s performance.
The validation supports the conclusions of the completion report, which found the CSP to be generally relevant. It was well aligned with Chad’s national priorities, the Bank’s strategic priorities, and the country’s fragility context. Although coordination mechanisms remained largely informal and the synergy between lending and non-lending operations were not sufficiently documented, the strategy demonstrated overall satisfactory coherence. In terms of effectiveness, overall performance was mixed. The validation estimates that 55.6% of indicators were fully or partially achieved, compared with 61% reported in the CSP Completion Report. The validation confirms that efficiency was constrained by significant implementation delays. As for sustainability prospects, they were deemed mixed. Achievements appear relatively sustainable in sectors though several factors continue to threaten the sustainability of results, including weak institutional capacity, lack of key expertise within the country office and uneven ownership of reforms.
In addition to the lessons learned from the completion report, the validation highlights the following lessons:
1.Strengthen the strategic framework and monitoring and evaluation system to improve decision-making, intervention coherence, selectivity, and accountability.
2.Systematically integrate fragility considerations into the design of lending and non-lending operations, the choice of instruments, and risk analysis to enhance the effectiveness and impact of interventions.
3. Ensure the availability of the relevant expertise and the stability of project implementation teams to support effective programme delivery.
4. Maintain a structured dialogue with government authorities and development partners to strengthen coordination, synergies, transparency, effectiveness, and the sustainability of interventions.