Independent Development Evaluation (IDEV) of the African Development Bank Group (AfDB or “the Bank”) conducted an evaluation synthesis of Public Financial Management (PFM). The purpose of the evaluation synthesis was to take stock of current knowledge and lessons on support provided for building effective and resilient PFM systems from evaluations conducted by various development partners, including the AfDB, multilateral and bilateral agencies, and Regional Member Countries.
The synthesis was based on a review of 70 evaluations covering around 600 PFM interventions valued at US$159 billion, spanning from 2012 to 2023. The evidence showed that PFM interventions tended to follow a uniform approach, despite efforts to tailor reforms to specific country contexts. Effective PFM interventions were found to have a sound understanding of the context and align with national priorities, have clear objectives, a clear scope, good quality, realistic indicators, key stakeholder participation in the design process, and provision for monitoring and evaluation, among others. Many PFM interventions were found to have provided poor advice and promoted inappropriate reform models. The evaluations reviewed mostly had evidence for outputs and short-term outcomes of PFM interventions, with limited evidence about their sustainability.
Key lessons emphasized the importance of coordination between development partners and country stakeholders to ensure focused, good-quality PFM interventions with realistic targets and underlined the importance of comprehensive context analysis, alignment with national priorities, clear objectives, risk management, cost-effectiveness, and inclusiveness in the design and implementation of PFM interventions.
Task Manager: Ms. Leticia TAIMO, Senior Evaluation Officer, IDEV.2