Evaluation Week 2024

titleIntroduction

The African Development Bank’s biennial “Evaluation Week” held on 17-19 September 2024, and organized by the Independent Development Evaluation (IDEV) function of the Bank is pleased to share with you some of the knowledge shared during this important learning event.

It was a hybrid event with participants from across the globe, the theme of this year’s event was  "Navigating rough seas towards a brighter horizon for Africa."  The structure and format of this edition provided a platform to explore how enhancing the acquisition and utilization of evaluative knowledge can leverage opportunities to overcome challenges and offering a forward-looking perspective on strengthening Africa’s capacity to address complex economic, social, and environmental issues. 

Evaluation Week 2024 provided a platform for advocating and facilitating dialogue on the critical use of evaluative knowledge in Africa, with a specific focus on evidence needed for monitoring progress, enhancing accountability, promoting learning and adaptation, guiding resource allocation, establishing and nurturing partnerships, and fostering stakeholder engagement.

Evaluation Week 2024 attracted a diverse group of speakers and participants, with over 700 attendees from various organizations, including multilateral development banks, development partners, academia, civil society, government, the private sector, and industry players.

Evaluation Week 2024 Program

Jump to your chosen session : 

17 September 2024 See the event program

18 September 2024 See the event program

19 September 2024 See the event program


 


Pre-conference workshops

Day 1 | 17 September 2024 | 09:00 - 12:00

The event began with two well-attended capacity development pre-conference workshops on topics where IDEV has identified opportunities for growth and innovation. Held simultaneously, the two workshops were entitled “Innovative Methods for Impact Assessment in Cross-Cutting Development Initiatives”; and “Cutting-Edge Approaches to Communicating Evaluative Insights”. IDEV staff were joined by experts from the International Initiative for Impact Evaluation (3ie), the West African Capacity Building and Impact Evaluation Program (WACIE), the Asian Development Bank (AsDB), the Global Evaluation Initiative of the World Bank (GEI-WB), the Independent Evaluation Group of the World Bank (IEG-WB) and the International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD).  

Presentation by Anca Dumitrescu & Deo-Gracias Houndolo (workshop 1)

3ie IE Methods Decision Tree handout_intermediate (workshop 1)

Handout_ResourcesAfDB (workshop 1)

Presentation by Patrizia Cocca (workshop 2)

Presentation by Jacqueline Nyagahima (workshop 2)


 


Opening Session: Navigating rough seas towards a brighter horizon for Africa

Day 1 | 17 September 2024 | 14:00 - 16:00

 

opening session

In her welcome remarks, Karen Rot-Münstermann, Evaluator General, AfDB presented the theme of the event and explained the rationale for the choice of sessions over the three days. She encouraged online attendees to participate in strategic discussions on evaluation in guiding future operations at the African Development Bank. 

Opening remarks were delivered by Marie-Laure Akin-Olugbade, Vice-President for the Regional Development, Integration and Business Delivery Complex at the African Development Bank. She commended IDEV for timely delivery of evaluative knowledge that provides a transparent view of results and performance for the Bank. She added that this also contributes to the recognition by the Bank Aid transparency index as the most transparent Institution in Africa. 

The keynote speech on the theme of “Reimagining Economic Growth in Africa” was delivered by Mayowa Kuyoro, Partner and Head of Africa Financial Services Group and EEMA Fintech and Payments Practice Leader , McKinsey & Company, Africa. After explaining that Africa is experiencing a fundamental structural switch away from agriculture and extraction, towards services, she said that going forward, it is important to achieve value addition for exported products and services and exploit the demographic dividend of a rising population of young workers. She concluded that improving productivity is key to economic growth and that digitalization of the economy and African talent are important elements of a future solution.

The session continued with a panel discussion “Building the Blocks of Change in Africa: How has Evaluative Knowledge Contributed to Enhancing Effectiveness and Impact of Development Institutions?” Panelists discussed different perspectives of how evaluative knowledge can address economic stability, climate change and social equity, the organization of an evaluation culture and the role of civil society in ensuring governments and development organizations are accountable, and how  evaluation can address SDG Shortcomings.  

Moderator: Armand Nzeyimana, Director, Development Impact and Results Department (SNDR), AfDB 
Panelists: Mette Knudsen, Executive Director and Chair of the Committee on Development Effectiveness (CODE), AfDB; Marcelin Cissé, Director General of Planning, Ministry of Economy, Planning and Development, Côte d’Ivoire; Dr. Hanan Morsy, Deputy Executive Secretary, Programme, and Chief Economist, United Nations Economic Commission for Africa (UNECA); and  Mavis Owusu-Gyamfi, President and Chief Executive Officer, African Center for Economic Transformation (ACET). 

See the report of McKinsey & Company

See the flickr album of photos from the opening and closing sessions.

AfDB Development Evaluation Week 2024 

Graphic illustration: Key takeaways from the Opening Session

opening


 

 

Accelerating Economic Diversification: Transformative Findings and Lessons from Development Assistance Initiatives

 

Day 2 | 18 September 2024 | 09:00 - 12:00

An introductory address by Eric Ogunleye, Director, the African Development Institute, African Development Bank entitled “The Current Landscape of Economic Diversification in Africa,” explained that Africa today lags other continents and the level of diversification has barely evolved over the last 30 years.  Domestic production, government revenue distribution and trade diversification are the three areas that impact a national economy and should be the focus areas for African countries. He added that it was important to have a resource-based industrialization strategy and to create a conducive business environment, including government reforms to tackle investment bottlenecks and corruption.

The session pursued with a roundtable discussion on the theme of "Analysis of Key Factors Contributing to Success, the Lessons Drawn, and Implications for Policy and Practice Associated with Economic Diversification." Panelists agreed that removing barriers to regional trade and establishing common markets are key to achieving the scale necessary for economic diversification. Countries need to work on sustainable policies, since economic diversification is invariably affected by political changes. At regional level, panelists spoke of the deplorable lack of political will to implement free trade agreements between countries. They also discussed the importance of value chains and additionality, concurring that technical and soft skills in the job market are key to attracting the private sector and spurring diversification. 

Moderator: Aissa Touré-Sarr, Country Manager Rwanda (CORW), AfDB
Panelists:
Mohamed El Habib Touré , Director of Investment Analysis and Monitoring, Investment Promotion Agency of Mauritania (APIM); Andson Nsune, Principal Evaluation Officer, IDEV-AfDB; and Boris Honkpehedji, Regional Non-Sovereign Operations Lead, Private Sector Development Department (PISD), AfDB

View session material : 

Presentation by Eric Ogunleye

Graphic illustration: Key takeaways from the Economic Diversification session

diversification


 

 

Thriving amidst Environmental and Climate Challenges: Evaluative Insights 

Day 2 | 18 September 2024 | 14:00 - 16:00  

cc

This session discussed key evidence on partnerships and collaborations that have yielded transformational actions towards environmental and climate resilience in Africa.

Geeta Batra, Director - Independent Evaluation Office, Global Environment Facility (GEF) set the scene in her presentation, the need for sustainable development to counter the triple planetary crisis of climate change, biodiversity loss and pollution. She insisted that sustainability is not limited to finance and availability of funding for projects. Policy reforms, risk management and evaluating and learning in real-time are also key to improving sustainability.

The session pursued with a roundtable discussion on the theme of "Thriving Amidst Environmental and Climate Challenges: Evaluative Insights." The panelists agreed on the multiple linkages between agriculture, water and energy and the need to avoid silos in development. The session drew examples of how technology and digital platforms were being used to tackle climate change, enabling education and capacity building in local languages. An example of sustainable solutions given was that of  remote sensing and digitalization technologies that are helping to transform the agriculture sector, for example by delivering early warnings for environmental events. The technologies allowed smallholder farmers to plan ahead and minimize the risks of losing their harvest. From a perspective of evaluation, science and digital dissemination have a critical role to play in addressing challenges. We rely on their production of quality data and on the dissemination of knowledge products to engage with stakeholders and enhance learning. Evaluations also have a role to play in that they present compelling evidence to attract finance. 

Moderator: João Duarte Cunha, Division Manager, Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Department (PERN), AfDB
Discussants:
Prof. Anthony O. Nyong, Director, Climate Change and Green Growth Department (PECG), AfDB; Svetlana Negroustoueva, Lead, Independent Evaluation Function,Independent Advisory and Evaluation Service (IAES), Consortium of International Agricultural Research Centers (CGIAR); Hanna Karima Schweitzer, Knowledge Management Analyst , Climate Investment Funds (CIF); Ahmed Fathy, Founder and CEO of the Youth Love Egypt Foundation (YLE); and Prof. Abukari Wumbei, Senior Research Fellow and Deputy Director, Drylands Research Institute,  Ghana. 

View session material : 

Presentation by Geeta Batra 

Graphic illustration: Key takeaways from the Environmental and Climate Challenges session

environment


 

 

Strategic evolution of the fragility lens for transformational change

Day 3 | 19 September 2024 | 09:00 - 12:00  

fragility

This session examined how evaluative knowledge has influenced the integration of the fragility lens in strategy design and implementation processes.

In his presentation of the session, Frederic Teufel, Lead Coordinator (policy, Knowledge), Transition States Coordination Office, AfDB, informed the panel that to enhances quality of entry of project design, all Bank projects undergo an assessment to ensure they contribute to building resilience, and that the overarching principle for the Bank’s interventions in fragile situations was to make sure that investments do no harm ! A programmatic approach guides the resource allocation and increases intentionality of the Bank’s financing.

The session continued with a roundtable discussion on the theme of "Leveraging Evaluative Knowledge for Effective Fragility and Resilience Strategies in Africa: Successes and Challenges." Panelists were in agreement on the need for a paradigm shift away from short-term humanitarian aid towards long-term transformative solutions that address the root causes of the conflict. To achieve this would take innovative financing and a shared vision between governments. financial institutions, civil society and other partnerships, particularly with the private sector. Experience had shown that partnerships should aim at having strong complementarity of mandates to take them to scale and address the complexity of fragility, among them climate change, energy or economic shocks. In terms of evaluative knowledge, there was a need for evaluations which look at our partnerships and how we can establish a common vision going forward. 

Moderator: Frederik Teufel, Lead Coordinator (policy, Knowledge), Transition States Coordination Office, AfDB
Panelists:
Daniel Ndoye, Country Manager Burkina Faso (COBF), AfDB; Margot van der Velden, Regional Director-West Africa, World Food Programme (WFP); and Fidy Rajaonson, Manager, Development Centre of Expertise, International Committee of the Red Cross(ICRC)

Graphic illustration: Key takeaways from the Fragility Lens session

fragility


 

Thursday 19th September

Evaluating for Impact: Improving the quality of life, and Closing Ceremony

Day 3 | 19 September 2024 | 14:00 - 17:00  

 quality

This session centered on the importance of evaluation as a tool to be used by communities to make informed decisions. Women and youth were at the forefront of presentations made by Madhusoodhanan (Madhu) Mampuzhasseril, who draw some lessons from some recent IDEV evaluations on health and economic empowerment interventions and Hope Chipanila, who spoke of an evaluation in Malawi that examined unintended consequences of an Urban Cash Intervention in Malawi during the COVID-19 pandemic.  

The lightning talk delivered by Isabelle Mercier focused on the active participation of communities in development projects, rather than targeting them as beneficiaries. Sakina B. Mwinyimkuu gave an example of how an evaluation informed the Tanzanian government on why the population was not using the electricity provided by a rural electrification program. The program was adjusted to provide solar panels for domestic use, making it more human-centered and relevant for the population. Paulin Basinga advocated for the equality of chance for children, too often left behind due to malnutrition from birth and, and therefore unable to contribute to Africa’s demographic dividend. Speaking specifically on the youth segment, Oswald Wedam Anonadaga and Tapera Jeffrey Muzira, the two discussants, concurred that young people are an asset for Africa and they should be invested in sufficiently to enable them to serve the continent. This involves adequate training to fit market opportunities, including in sectors of creative industries such as music, drama or sports; enabling a business environment, and unlocking affordable access to finance for youth entrepreneurs. 

Presentations: 
Madhusoodhanan (Madhu) Mampuzhasseril, Division Manager, IDEV, AfDB
Hope Chipanila, Economist, Ministry of Economic Planning and Development, Malawi

Moderator: May Mwaka, Principal Evaluation Officer, IDEV-AfDB
Speakers:
Isabelle Mercier, Director, Independent Evaluation Office, United Nations Development Programme  (UNDP); Sakina B. Mwinyimkuu, Director of Performance Monitoring and Evaluation, Prime Minister’s Office, United Republic of Tanzania; and Dr. Paulin Basinga, Director, Africa-Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation
Discussants:
Tapera Jeffrey Muzira, Lead Expert, Jobs for Youth in Africa Strategy,Human Capital, Youth and Skills Development Department (AHHD), AfDB; and Oswald Wedam Anonadaga, Founder and CEO Floodgates Ltd, Ghana

The closing ceremony at the AfDB headquarters, CCIA building in Abidjan, Côte d'Ivoire, featured a presentation of the Bank's new Ten-Year Strategy by Caroline Kende-Robb, Director, Strategy and Operational Policies, (SNSP), AfDB,  and a presentation of visual notes taken over the three days of discussion, by illustrator Virginie Menot.  The AfDB Evaluator General, Karen Rot-Münstermann closed the 6th edition, commending participants for their constructive contributions and willingness to share their valuable experience.    

View session materials :

Presentation by Madhusoodhanan (Madhu) Mampuzhasseril

Presentation by Hope Chipanila

Presentation by Sakina B. Mwinyimkuu

Presentation by Caroline Kende-Robb

Graphic illustration: Key takeaways from the Quality of Life session

Quality of life