Comparative Study of Multilateral Development Bank Operating Models

Date: 04/10/2024

Type: Comparative Study

Country(ies): 

Status: Completed

The Independent Development Evaluation (IDEV) at the African Development Bank (AfDB) conducted a comparative study on the operating models of six Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs), notably, the World Bank, the Asian Development Bank, the Islamic Development Bank, the InterAmerican Development Bank, the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development and the AfDB. The study focused on three topics, namely, decentralization, the "One Bank" approach, and synergies between sovereign and non-sovereign operations (SO/NSO), operations (SO/NSO), to explore and compare different models and to identify lessons and good practices across MDBs.

Findings show that decentralization has contributed to enhanced client relations and responsiveness but poses challenges like maintaining cohesion and career progression for local staff in some organizations. MDBs have also adopted various "One Bank" approaches to break down silos and improve internal collaboration, but success has been mixed, with some organizations struggling to implement cohesive strategies.

Synergies between SO and NSO operations have been pursued, with joint project development and collaboration yielding positive results in some instances. However, challenges remain, such as aligning incentives and coordinating units. The study noted that few MDBs track progress on decentralization, the "One Bank" approach, or SO/NSO collaboration in their results frameworks, limiting their ability to monitor success.

Key lessons include the necessity of setting clear decentralization objectives, implementing strong monitoring systems, and fostering collaboration between SOs and NSOs. A well-defined "One Bank" vision, supported by incentives, is important to enhance cohesion and operational success.

 

Task Manager: Latéfa CAMARA, Senior Evaluation Officer