Evaluation of the Implementation of the AfDB Selectivity Framework

Date: 28/04/2026

Type: Thematic evaluation

Country(ies): 

Status: Completed

Independent Development Evaluation (IDEV) at the African Development Bank (AfDB or “the Bank”) evaluated the implementation of the AfDB’s Selectivity Framework over 2013–2024, examining its design, evolution, and application, and assessing whether it helped the Bank become more focused, strategically coherent, efficient, and transformative.

The evaluation found that the framework was conceptually relevant and strengthened the Bank’s strategic narrative, but its operational influence remained limited. Reported alignment with strategic priorities increased significantly after 2021, yet this did not translate into systematic changes in portfolio composition or investment decisions. In practice, the Framework functioned more as a reporting and validation tool than as an instrument for shaping investment choices.

Four main factors explain this: It did not adequately manage the trade-off between selectivity and client responsiveness; its broad priorities enabled high formal alignment but provided limited guidance for real prioritization; institutional incentives and performance metrics continued to reward volume, approvals, and speed; and the framework lacked clear mechanisms for contextual adaptation and consistent enforcement.

Key lessons highlight the limits of treating selectivity as a reporting tool, the need to align incentives, and the importance of context-specific guidance. The evaluation recommends reaffirming the Bank’s commitment to selectivity, strengthening framework design, and improving its implementation.

Evaluation Task Manager: Joseph MOUANDA, Chief Evaluation Officer