Independent Development Evaluation (IDEV) carried out a cluster evaluation of 18 African Development Bank Group (AfDB or “the Bank”) transport projects in the road transport and ports/water & fluvial transport sub-sectors, comprising eight completed or close to completed projects (USD 805.5 million) and ten recently approved projects (USD 1.2 billion) over the 2012-2019 period.
The evaluation aimed to draw lessons from the design and implementation of road and port projects in order to provide insights for future strategic and operational directions for the Bank’s assistance in the transport sector and to inform any revision to the AfDB Transport Policy (1993).
Selected findings:
- The reviewed projects supported African countries in their need to expand their transport network and services, which were identified as investment priorities by the countries themselves.
- Private sector involvement in transport financing improved efficiency, but the financial risks remain high.
- The appraisal reports of the recently approved projects were found to show a good understanding of the main issues that can negatively affect project implementation and sustainability, but did not display new approaches to address these problems.
Selected lessons:
- Greater development outcomes can be achieved through more thoughtful design and follow-up of project ancillary components, and exploiting synergies with other development projects.
- The timely implementation of transport projects can be improved if binding constraints are removed.
- Embedding a revenue-generating mechanism in transport projects can effectively address the lack of funding and capacity for maintenance.
Task Manager: Clement Banse, Chief Evaluation Officer, IDEV
Financial amounts provided are converted from the AfDB’s unit of account at the exchange rate of August 2021
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| Transport Cluster Summary Report (En)-Web.pdf | 3.3 MB |
| Technical Annexes | 1.26 MB |
| Executive Summary-Transport Cluster Summary Report (En)-Web.pdf | 444.99 KB |
| Transport Cluster Evaluation Inception Report | 1.27 MB |