Amplifying the voices of citizens: Strengthening data systems

14 July, 2021
Evaluation Matters Magazine:
CSOs in evaluation edition

Karen Bett, Global Partnership for Sustainable Development Data

Citizen-generated data (CGD) has a high potential to monitor and drive progress on a country’s development, including towards Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), as well as to help amplify citizens’ voices and their perspectives on development. However, there are limitations in CGD and challenges for its use. This article argues that National Statistical Offices can support and guide citizen-generated data initiatives to comply with statistical quality standards and improve their usefulness.

Key messages

  • Official statistics have traditionally been relied upon in measuring progress against commitments. However, with advances in technology, alternative data sources such as citizen-generated data (CGD) have become increasingly relevant to help close the data gap.
  • Despite its potential, CGD is perceived to lack credibility due to its limitations of low coverage and the number of sufficient initiatives to represent a population or area of interest.
  • With the stewardship of National Statistical Offices (NSOs), civil society can conduct citizen-generated data initiatives that comply with statistical quality standards similar to those used by NSOs.
  • Producing guidelines that provide a “translation” of statistical concepts, principles, and processes into everyday language will enable civil society organizations to produce high-quality data that complies with quality standards.
  • Beyond guidelines, more investment efforts should be targeted towards strengthening CGD.

Context

The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (the Agenda 2030), adopted by all United Nations Members States in 2015, reflects a unique global consensus and commitment to address the world’s most acute and pressing development challenges to leave no one behind. With less than ten years to go to 2030, the need to accelerate progress could not be more urgent than now. To accelerate progress, quality data needs to be available to guide informed decisions on implementing and reviewing the 2030 Agenda. 

The UN Secretary-General’s Sustainable Development Goals Progress Report for 2019 highlights that many national statistical systems worldwide face serious challenges in having the right amount and quality of data to measure progress.  The result: accurate and timely information about the lives of people is unknown. Numerous groups and individuals remain “invisible,” and many development challenges are still poorly understood.  

New data sources and technologies for data collection and the integration of various data sources- such as citizen-generated data and big data- need to be continually explored to generate necessary quality data. This requires partnerships across governments, civil society, the private sector, and academia.  

Citizen-generated data (CGD) has a high potential to monitor and drive progress on a country’s development, including towards Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). Citizen-generated data is defined as data that people or their organizations produce to monitor, demand directly, or drive change on issues that affect them. This can be produced through crowdsourcing mechanisms or citizen reporting initiatives, often organized and managed by civil society groups (Wilson, Christopher and Zara Rahman 2015, p.16). It is grounded in the local context- including in geographies and demographics that are hard to reach. Therefore, one of its purposes is to help amplify citizens’ voices and their perspectives on development.  It is actively given by citizens, providing direct representations of their views and an alternative to governments or international institutions' datasets. As such, CGD allows governments to innovate ways to engage their citizens and improve evidence-based decision-making. Importantly, CGD provides a great opportunity to complement official statistics produced by National Statistical Offices and, therefore, a useful data source for measuring the SDGs. Table 1 documents the various ways that CGD helps to achieve the SDGs. 

Table 1: How CGD can help achieve the Sustainable Development Goals

Relation to SDGs CGD can play the following roles
Citizenship: Creating new relationships and public spaces

- Be a venue for local development and education strategies.
- Provide the frame for outreach and engagement with special interest communities.
- Enhance and innovate governments’ engagement strategies with citizens.
- Provide localized statistics; CGD is detailed because citizens can be more knowledgeable on the issues surrounding them.

Monitoring: Informing, expanding, and improving SDG monitoring -Produce data in hard-to-reach regions.
- Identify patterns hidden behind averages.
- Improve the capacity of states to detect issues.
- Cross-verify government data with CGD and vice versa. For example: Since 1999, Afrobarometer has conducted public opinion surveys on democracy, governance, the economy, and society in more than 30 countries on the continent and repeated on a regular cycle.
Implementation: Informing public policy goals and community-driven problem solving - Provide baseline data for research and test assumptions.
- Enable planning, strategy development, and resource allocation.
- Monitor performance of public facilities.
- Identify root causes around problems. For example, CGD has proven useful during responses to natural disasters, such as the April 2015 earthquake in Nepal. Volunteers for the Humanitarian Open Street Maps Team provided rescuers with much-needed local data.

Source : https://www.data4sdgs.org/resources/advancing-sustainability-together-citizen-generated-data-and-sustainable-development et https://www.data4sdgs.org/resources/choosing-and-engaging-citizen-generated-data-guide, site consulté en février 2020.

Despite its potential, the challenges and limitations of citizen-generated data have also been documented. These include the low coverage that these initiatives have, both from a geographical distribution and the number of sufficient initiatives to represent a population or area of interest. It is also difficult to compare CGD collected by different actors and in multiple countries, ­ often collected according to different methodologies, strategic priorities, and cultural and political contexts. All of the above have contributed to perceptions that citizen-generated data often lack credibility. As a result, governments are less likely to use or integrate it into their datasets (GPSDD, 2017).

As data stewards, the National Statistical Offices (NSOs) can support and guide citizen-generated data initiatives to comply with statistical quality standards. For example, the Philippines Statistics Agency (PSA) has developed a case study on CGD's potentials and features in the country and a quality assurance framework to guide civil society organizations (CSO) as they are key facilitators of CGD (Paris 21, 2020). They are in close touch with citizens and can work with them to collect and use CGD. CSOs need clear and easy-to-understand guidance on how to collect and process data in a way that conforms with the standards defined by NSOs. This can help address the issue of credibility, methodological variability of citizen generated data and could allow governments to use them better.

Kenya has been a top advocate of the 2030 Agenda and has reported its progress towards SDGs achievement in a Voluntary National Review (VNR) in 2017 and 2020. The SDGs are systematically mainstreamed in the third Medium Term Plan (MTP III 2018-2022) and in Vision2030, a development blueprint developed by the Kenyan government to turn the country into a newly industrializing, middle-income country providing a high quality life to all its citizens by the year 2030.

The Global Partnership for Sustainable Development Data (Global Partnership), with support from the German development agency, GIZ, has developed guidelines that enable non-state actors to produce citizen-generated data that fulfill government quality standards in Kenya. These guidelines provide a “translation” of statistical concepts, principles, and processes into every-day-language to enable civil society organizations to produce high-quality data that complies with quality standards defined by the Kenya National Bureau of Statistics. The guidelines are now available on the Global Partnership website.

Looking forward, there are increasing calls for more and better data in many African countries on the SDGs and national reporting. Developing and adhering to guidelines that enable non-state actors to produce citizen-generated data that fulfills government quality standards will play an important role in positioning CGD as good quality and fit for purpose.

Beyond guidelines, it is important to strengthen collaboration to enable sharing of lessons; within and across countries, among civil society, and  National Statistical Offices. Strengthening CGD calls for increased investments to strengthen data capacity within civil society. Furthermore, investments should target strengthening National Statistical Offices to support CGD. This will enable them to spearhead activities that institutionalize CGD, such as conducting data gaps assessments and developing quality criteria to assess and accept CGD for reporting and decision-making.

Photo by Lagos Techie on Unsplash

References:

Wilson, Christopher and Zara Rahman. 2015. Citizen-generated data and governments: Towards a collaborative model, DataShift,  civicus.org/images/citizen-generated%20data%20and%20governments.pdf

GPSDD, 2017. Making Use of Citizen Generated Data http://www.data4sdgs.org/sites/default/files/2017-09/Making%20Use%20of%20Citizen-Generated%20Data%20-%20Data4SDGs%20Toolbox%20Module.pdf

Paris 21, 2020. Use of CGD for SDG reporting in the Philippines: A case study, https://paris21.org/sites/default/files/inline-files/PSA-report-FINAL.pdf. Paris: self-publication


Karen Bett,

Karen Bett

Karen Bett is the Policy Officer for the Global Partnership for Sustainable Development Data. She conducts research and policy analysis on data for development and supports the organization’s work on population data. She completed her MA in Economics, specializing in health economics and public finance, at the University of Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. Karen can be reached at  [email protected] and/or subscribe to the GPSDD newsletter

Image