Evaluation of Counterpart Funding at the AfDB

Date: 14/06/2024

Type: Corporate evaluation

Country(ies): 

Status: Completed

Independent Development Evaluation (IDEV) at the African Development Bank Group (AfDB or "the Bank") conducted an evaluation of Counterpart Funding (CF) in sovereign operations of the AfDB over the period 2009-2022. The evaluation assessed how the flexibility on counterpart funding introduced in the ongoing 2008 Policy on Expenditure Eligible for Bank Group Financing met the policy’s objectives for risk-sharing and country ownership, and the Bank’s implementation performance.

The evaluation found that overall, the rationale to increase CF flexibility was based on solid foundations, the policy has remained largely coherent with the Bank’s broader policy framework and has exhibited strong similarities with Multilateral Development Banks’(MDBs) CF policy frameworks. However, the policy was found to have some oversights, notably concerning co-financing, the exclusion of certain types of sovereign operations, and the treatment of in-kind contributions, and it needs to be updated to reflect organizational changes. In terms of effectiveness, the introduction of CF flexibility has reduced the risk of poor project performance due to delayed or non-payment of CF, although some issues persist. The decision to cost share comes partly down to governments’ preferences or legal requirements, and a causal link between CF requirements and ownership could not be verified. CF requirements were found to have very little effect on risk-sharing. Regarding efficiency, the evaluation found that stakeholders did not always implement the policy requirements correctly with some important variations in its implementation. Moreover, the findings suggested that in terms of transaction costs, the Bank’s approach to implementing the policy is significantly more onerous than the approach used in other MDBs. 

The evaluation recommended that the Bank update the 2008 policy provision on counterpart funding to ensure its continued relevance, while maintaining the possibility to fund up to 100% of total project costs, to ensure consistency in policy implementation, and to enhance the efficiency of the policy’s implementation by removing the duplication of requiring both the use of country financing parameters and project-level justifications for cost-sharing flexibility. 

Task Manager: Samson K. Houetohossou, Principal Evaluation Officer