19-November-2024
In the face of climate change, economic instability, and political volatility, resilience has become an increasingly critical concept for countries across Africa. However, resilience means different things in different places, shaped by each nation’s unique challenges, needs, and context. From managing frequent flooding in coastal regions to combating economic shocks in oil-dependent countries, resilience requires a multifaceted, locally tailored approach. At the African Development Bank (AfDB), resilience is at the heart of its Ten-Year Strategy (2024–2033), which seeks to address Africa’s vulnerabilities to climate change, conflict, and economic crises. But how can we measure and build resilience across diverse African contexts? IDEV’s (Independent Development Evaluation) efforts in this space provide a critical lens for understanding and strengthening resilience-building interventions.
Resilience: A Complex and context-dependent concept
Resilience is a nuanced and evolving concept. What it looks like in one country may differ dramatically from what it means in another. For instance, in flood-prone countries, resilience may focus on improving disaster preparedness and flood management systems, while in regions suffering from economic instability, it might be centered around diversification and fostering economic self-sufficiency. These variances call for tailored interventions that reflect the unique challenges of each country or region.
The AfDB’s new Ten-Year Strategy addresses resilience as a core component of Africa's development agenda, focusing on five key areas: infrastructure strengthening, economic diversification, social system improvements, environmental management, and institutional capacity building. IDEV's role is to evaluate and support the implementation of resilience-building strategies in these areas, ensuring that interventions are designed and executed with the utmost attention to local contexts.
Tools and approaches for measuring resilience bridge contextual differences and inform the design and implementation of effective interventions.
At IDEV, we employ a range of evaluation tools and methodologies to measure resilience, bridge contextual differences, and inform the design and implementation of effective interventions. These tools are designed to capture the complexities of resilience and to ensure that interventions are responsive to the unique needs of each country. Here are some of the key tools and methodologies we use:
- Contextualized Evaluations: Understanding the specific context of a country is crucial for evaluating resilience. IDEV tailors its evaluations to each country's conditions. For instance, in the evaluation of the Nigeria Country Strategy and Program (2004-2016) and the CSP 2020-2024 Mid Term Review, the AfDB's strategic focus in Nigeria has been on enhancing infrastructure, governance, and economic diversification to reduce the country's reliance on oil and promote sustainable development. In contrast, in Mauritius, where urbanization and climate risks like heavy rainfall are pressing concerns, we assessed resilience within the context of wastewater management. By adjusting evaluations to each country's needs, IDEV ensures that its findings and recommendations are grounded in local realities.
- Expanded theory of change: At IDEV, we also use an expanded theory of change, which goes beyond the traditional linear approach to understanding how interventions lead to resilience outcomes. For example, in evaluating the Lake Chad Basin Resilience Program, we identified resilience outcomes related to food security, livelihood diversification, and conflict mitigation, all of which were influenced by environmental degradation and cross-border conflicts. This approach uses a system-based perspective to adjust strategies and account for complex, interrelated factors such as climate change and shifting agricultural practices.
- Participatory approaches. We prioritize local stakeholder perspectives in our evaluations, as community engagement is crucial for building resilience. In projects like the Kenya Green Zones Development Support Project, which focuses on reforestation and natural resource management, IDEV engaged local communities to understand the project’s impact on their resilience to drought and soil erosion. This participatory approach ensures that our evaluations capture the real experiences of the people directly affected by these interventions.
- Knowledge sharing and learning. Evaluations are only useful when their insights are shared and acted upon. IDEV is committed to knowledge dissemination to improve AfDB’s resilience-building work. For instance, our evaluation on green growth and climate change guided the development of the AfDB’s Climate and Green Growth Strategic Framework for 2021-2030, ensuring that the Bank's future strategies are informed by lessons learned from past initiatives.
- Mixed methods and geospatial analysis. Given the complexity of resilience, we employ both quantitative and qualitative methods to capture the multifaceted nature of this concept. By combining traditional evaluation methods with geospatial analysis, we can visualize patterns and trends that help us understand how resilience varies across different regions and contexts, leading to more comprehensive and actionable insights.
Resilience design and monitoring tool
Resilience is a multifaceted concept that manifests at individual, household, and community levels. Due to its complexity, no single indicator can comprehensively capture resilience. Various organizations have developed distinct measures to evaluate resilience.
The African Development Bank (AfDB) employs several tools and methodologies to assess and enhance climate resilience in its projects and member countries. They include:
- Climate Safeguards System (CSS) : The CSS is a set of decision-making tools and guidelines that enable the Bank to screen projects for climate change-related risks and identify appropriate adaptation measures to reduce project vulnerability. It includes modules for climate screening, adaptation review and evaluation procedures, country adaptation factsheets, and an information base with climate projections and adaptation activities.
- Country Resilience and Fragility Assessment (CRFA): The CRFA tool offers a method of assessing resilience and fragility using seven key criteria: political inclusiveness, safety and security, justice, the economy, social cohesion, the regional contagion effect, and climate change. This comprehensive approach allows the Bank to tailor its interventions to the specific resilience and fragility context of each country.
Other International Organizations utilize different resilience measures including (Figure 1):
- The Resilience design and monitoring tool (RDMT) The RDMT aims at providing a framework for building the resilience of rural households and a step-by-step guide to designing for and monitoring the performance of resilience-building interventions during project implementation.
- The Ability to Recover (ATR) Index is a metric used by the International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) to assess how effectively communities rebound from climate-related and other shocks. It evaluates the resilience of communities by comparing regions with and without resilience investments, using data from resilience surveys.
- Community-based resilience analysis (CoBRA) . is a participatory assessment tool developed by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) to evaluate and enhance the resilience of communities facing various shocks and stresses. Unlike traditional assessments that rely on predefined indicators, CoBRA emphasizes local perceptions, allowing communities to define what resilience means to them and identify the factors that contribute to it.
- The Resilience Index Measurement and Analysis II (RIMA-II) is a quantitative tool developed by the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) to assess household resilience to food insecurity. It evaluates the capacity of households to withstand and recover from various shocks, such as economic downturns, natural disasters, or conflicts.
- Oxfam GB Multidimensional resilience Measurement . Oxfam Great Britain (GB) has developed a Multidimensional Approach to Measuring Resilience to assess and enhance the capacity of communities to withstand and recover from various shocks and stresses. This approach recognizes that resilience is a complex, multifaceted concept that cannot be captured through a single indicator.
- Resilience Capacity Index. The Resilience Capacity Index (RCI) is a metric developed to assess the ability of communities to withstand and recover from various shocks and stresses, such as economic downturns, natural disasters, or social disruptions. It provides a composite measure of resilience by evaluating multiple dimensions that contribute to a community's overall capacity to adapt and thrive in the face of adversity.
Advancing climate resilience in Africa: IDEV's role
As Africa faces the brunt of the climate crisis, resilience becomes especially critical. IDEV plays a vital role in building the evidence base for informed decision-making and policy development around adaptation and resilience to climate change. Our evaluations focus on energy, climate change, and green growth initiatives, generating insights that inform the AfDB's strategies for climate resilience.
For example, our evaluation on mainstreaming green growth and climate change helped shape the AfDB’s Climate and Green Growth Strategic Framework, ensuring that the Bank’s interventions are aligned with global climate goals. Similarly, evaluations on renewable energy initiatives have shown how AfDB's projects have enhanced energy access, reduced emissions, and promoted sustainable economic development.
Beyond generating evaluative knowledge, IDEV is committed to knowledge sharing to amplify the impact of its evaluations. We have actively engaged in global climate dialogues, including COP events, to position evaluation as a key component in shaping effective climate action. For instance, IDEV contributed a background paper to COP27, summarizing key evaluative insights on climate resilience, and we are planning to contribute to the Evidence for Action pavilion at future COP events.
What policymakers should take to COP
IDEV's message to policymakers is clear: effective climate action in Africa requires strong international support to build local data systems, advance community-led adaptation, and promote cross-regional knowledge sharing. By investing in these areas, Africa can chart a sustainable, inclusive path to resilience that not only protects its communities but also sets a global example for climate adaptation.
Conclusion
In conclusion, resilience is a dynamic and context-dependent concept that requires tailored, evidence-based interventions. IDEV’s approach—through contextualized evaluations, participatory approaches, and the use of innovative tools like mixed methods and geospatial analysis—provides the insights needed to design effective resilience-building interventions. As Africa continues to grapple with the challenges of climate change, IDEV remains committed to building the evidence base that will guide policymakers, shape strategies, and contribute to the continent’s long-term resilience and sustainable development.