APNODE and IDEV participate in a discussion on Evidence Use by Parliaments during COVID-19

Wednesday 31 March 2021

On 31 March 2021, Hon Evelyn Mpagi-Kaabule, Chairperson of the African Parliamentarians’ Network on Development Evaluation (APNODE), participated in a webinar themed ‘Evidence Use by Parliaments during COVID’ organized by Twende Mbele and moderated by Dr. Kobena Hanson of Independent Development Evaluation at the African Development Bank (IDEV/AfDB). Other speakers were Senator Sylvia Mueni Kasanga of the Parliament of Kenya, and Dr. Wilhelm Janse van Rensburg of the Parliament of South Africa.

The objective of the webinar was to assess the effects of COVID on the oversight and representation functions of parliaments, the uptake of evidence, and its use in response to the pandemic. Dr. Hanson introduced the topic by highlighting how the COVID-19 pandemic has not only disrupted the lives of almost everyone, including elected officials, but also transformed how MPs have utilized evidence to reshape parliaments’ oversight function, and how parliaments to hold the executive accountable.

Hon. Mpagi-Kaabule drew on the Ugandan experience to highlight how the pandemic has brought many innovations into parliaments, and that the lessons learned should be a motivation to rethink traditional processes, for example holding legislative debates and committee meetings in a virtual format. Hon Mpagi-Kaabule also suggested that innovations in technology could help parliaments enhance transparency and accountability.

Sen. Kasanga’s presentation focused on evidence use in the Kenyan Parliament during COVID-19. She pointed out that during the lockdown period she had the opportunity to chair the Senate Ad Hoc Committee on COVID-19, which leveraged different types of evidence including rigorous scientific data, human impact stories, observational data, and policy best practices from other countries to verify and ground truth developments.

Her presentation was followed by Dr. Janse van Rensburg who highlighted that the functions of parliament did not necessarily change during COVID. However, COVID-19 affected the functioning of parliaments due to issues such as inactivity during the time of crisis, physical closure of parliaments, slow uptake of virtual platforms, as well as the risk of insufficient oversight of the security force by parliaments – leading to executive dominance and a securitization of policies. Nevertheless, as countries lessened lockdown measures, parliaments slowly regained their functions and in some cases improved their oversight roles.

Following the presentations, participants engaged with speakers on a host of issues including but not limited to executive dominance, role of civil society, and what the future of parliamentary evidence-use will look like. Following the question-answer session, the moderator drew the following take-aways:

  • COVID’s disruption of the day-to-day work of parliaments, gave the executive lots of power, resulting in ‘executive dominance’;
  • Many parliaments and MPs negotiated the pandemic with creativity, using new tools such virtual platforms and social media to verify and ground truth information;
  • Rise of virtual platforms, have heightened transparency as the public gained increased access to information;
  • ‘Securitization of the pandemic’ was widespread across many countries; and,
  • New tools helped improve oversight and enhanced in-depth inquiry.

The event was brought to a close on the promise to continue the conversation at the upcoming gLOCAL Evaluation Week.

Watch the recording of the webinar.

Tags